The College Football Coaching Carousel
The college football coaching carousel has entered its hiring season, with positions being filled in the Power 5 conferences. Each new hire brings hope and analysis, as previous coaching cycles have shown that some highly anticipated hires can miss the mark, while less-celebrated coaches can be exactly what certain programs need. In this article, we will break down the most notable new hires, discussing how the head coaches fit into their new roles and the challenges they will face. We will also provide an initial grade for each hire, which will be updated throughout the coaching carousel.
Mike Elko at Texas A&M
First, let’s look at Mike Elko’s hiring at Texas A&M. Elko, the former defensive coordinator under Jimbo Fisher, is seen as a good fit for the Aggies. Despite the hefty buyout paid to Fisher, Texas A&M prioritized finding a coach who fits the program rather than making a splash. Elko’s experience with the team and his success in overseeing a tough defense during Fisher’s best season at A&M make him a strong candidate. His biggest challenge will be molding the talented roster into a contender and addressing the program’s struggles in consistently winning on a national level. Overall, Elko receives a B+ grade, with time being the ultimate judge of his success.
Jeff Lebby at Mississippi State
Next, we have Jeff Lebby’s hiring at Mississippi State. Lebby, known for his work with explosive offenses, is seen as a good fit for a team that struggled offensively in the previous season. His track record in coaching quarterbacks and his experience at Ole Miss under Lane Kiffin should help him recruit in the state. However, as a first-time head coach in a challenging job, Lebby will need a comprehensive vision and plan to succeed. His off-field performance will also be closely watched due to his connection to Baylor and Art Briles. Lebby receives a B grade, with his offense being a positive aspect for recruits and fans.
Jonathan Smith at Michigan State
Moving on to Jonathan Smith’s hiring at Michigan State, he is seen as potentially becoming the offensive version of the successful Mark Dantonio. Smith’s eye for under-the-radar talent and his experience in winning at Oregon State make him a good fit for the Spartans. His biggest challenge will be rebuilding the team’s identity, particularly on defense, as the Spartans struggled in various defensive categories. Smith’s grade is an A, as he brings stability and a defined vision to a program in need of both.
David Braun at Northwestern
Lastly, David Braun’s hiring as the full-time head coach at Northwestern is seen as a good fit. Braun, who joined the program in January, has already shown success in improving the team’s record and gaining the trust of his players. However, there is uncertainty surrounding the university and athletic department leadership, as well as where the team will play its home games in the coming seasons. Braun’s challenge will be limiting portal exits and reshaping the team’s offensive philosophy. Despite these challenges, Northwestern made the right hire given the circumstances, and Braun receives a B+ grade.
In conclusion, these new coaching hires bring both hope and challenges to their respective programs. Only time will tell if they are the right fit and can lead their teams to success.